Relevance

Relevant language learning engages children and young people in motivating, meaningful learning experiences and purposeful pathways for languages and wider skills.

This section explores Relevance in relation to the following three How are we doing? self-evaluation statements:

  • Our curriculum is appropriate to our learners’ age and stage, and offers progressive pathways for all learners.
  • Our language learning is relevant to our learners’ interests and needs and we know this through embedding learner voice throughout our planning, our learning and teaching and our self-evaluation.
  • Our learners understand the range of skills gained through language learning including skills for life and work, literacy, intercultural competence, and global citizenship.

Click on the links below to read more about the key themes of Relevance and then use the How are we doing? statements to reflect on your current practice and explore your next steps.  Further reading and resources are also provided at the bottom of this page.

Developing relevant language learning

Education Scotland Building the Curriculum 3 defines relevance as a principle which should inform curricular planning, and day-to-day teaching and learning. In relation to planning, the principle of relevance:

“should be used to help those planning the curriculum in selecting content which connects with the child’s experience, learning and interests in and beyond the school environment.”

In relation to learning and teaching, Education Scotland note that class teachers should ensure that links are made to learners’ experiences, previous learning and interests, in order that learners can:

“understand the relevance of their classroom learning, for example seeing connections with experiences in their family or local community, the world of work, their experiences of travel or their interests in sport or media.”

(Education Scotland, 2008, P33)

Key considerations when planning relevant learning and teaching experiences include:

  • Learning themes and topics which reflect the interests of children and young people and provide rich and engaging contexts for learning
  • Inclusive and relevant contexts for learning which are at a similar conceptual level to other curricular areas
  • Learner voice is at the centre of planning. It is embedded in, and informs, curriculum design and the ongoing development and evaluation of learning contexts and learning experiences
  • Planning language learning experiences which engage with, and explore the world around us, and key contemporary issues (e.g. recycling, climate change and weather, public health)
  • Learning contexts which explore and engage in the world around us, key issues, and cultures

The following reflective questions can support planning:

  • Is there a clear purpose to learning?
  • Do our learners understand the purpose of their learning?
  • Is there depth of learning and challenge?
  • Does the learning develop thinking skills?
  • Does learning contribute coherently to wider learning and skills development across the curriculum?

Considering what we currently do and how we can extend or develop this to be more relevant and have more depth is a useful starting point for developing practice.  For example, when describing aspects of self, there are opportunities to explore how our lives, customs and culture compare with the lives of others.  Some examples are provided below:

Theme Possible wider development of learning
Describing appearance Customs and culture

My style, my identity

Hobbies How children / young people spend their free time in other countries and how does this compare with popular past times here? (e.g. what sports are most popular in France, Namibia, Germany, Mexico etc).

How do people listen to music, what music is most popular? How does particular music make you feel?  How do traditional / folk music from different countries compare? Etc.

Transport Patterns of local transport (walking, cycling, bus, car etc.), and then comparing this with patterns of local transport in another country, for example the Netherlands, where cycling is the norm.  There is the potential for interdisciplinary learning in exploring the factors that enable the high levels of bicycle use in the Netherlands and considering what would need to change to enable higher bicycle use in Scotland.

The Broad General Education (BGE) provides a flexible curriculum framework which enables learning to be developed in a range of ways, including across the curriculum.  Languages are at a particular advantage within this framework in that skills can be applied and developed in any context.  Best practice in approaches in primary school planning supports this approach, with cross-curriculum planning embedded and developed at all levels.  In both primary and secondary schools, language learning which is informed by learners’ needs and interests is better placed to develop learning through meaningful and engaging contexts.  By linking language learning across the curriculum, it is possible to consolidate and deepen prior learning and to apply skills in new contexts.

Possible BGE language learning contexts include:

  • Links to other areas of the curriculum e.g. STEM, Expressive Arts or Social Sciences
  • Global citizenship e.g. key principles of global citizenship, developing a sense of place in the world, breaking down stereotypes
  • Intercultural learning e.g. working with partners to share learning, explore global issues
  • Sustainability e.g. a focus on your local environment
  • Wider achievement e.g. volunteering, community partnerships
  • Employability and developing skills for work through language learning
  • Literacy across languages g. Improving reading outcomes and building confidence by reading in different languages
  • Practical life skills e.g. eating out, applying for a passport, planning travel, making a phone call, and travelling
  • Learning skills e.g. learner autonomy, self-efficacy, transferable language skills, developing strategies for effective language learning for life

By planning in partnership with learners to develop a shared sense of purpose and agreeing outcomes, language learning can become inherently more relevant and help to develop a greater sense of the benefits and positive impacts of their learning.

Languages as a life skill

Languages are a life skill. Through learning languages we develop transferable skills, a growth mindset and the competences required to apply our learning in a range of contexts throughout our lives.

Approaches to promoting languages as a life skill include:

  • Continuity of vision and planning for languages throughout the BGE which reinforce the principle that language learning is an entitlement for all, and that everyone is a language learner.
  • Messaging throughout the curriculum that languages are a key and useful skill which can be developed throughout the rest of your life. Applying languages in a range of school and out-of-school contexts to reinforce this message.
  • Explicit development of transferable language learning skills and strategies e.g. how we learn language, what helps us to learn, developing the confidence to talk in another language, discussion of how these skills are transferable skills across languages.
  • Linking to other speakers of the language e.g. partner schools at home and abroad, cultural agencies and institutes, native speaker programmes.
  • Making links with other young people e.g. language and culture exchange programmes with schools and sharing language, culture and learning.

Learner voice and relevance

Learner voice is key in ensuring that children and young people are engaged in, and see the relevance of, their languages learning. Asking learners key questions around their experiences of language learning shapes our understanding of how best to plan meaningful language learning which meet learners needs. Topics for discussion with learners may include themes such as:

  • Skills development e.g. to what extent do learners see themselves as developing useful skills through language learning?
  • Achievement e.g. do learners perceive that they are progressing and achieving in languages?
  • Inclusion e.g. is learning inclusive of multilingual learners, how do learners with additional support needs feel about their language learning? Are learners both supported and challenged?
  • Employability e.g. do learners feel that languages are a useful skill for future employability? Do learners have opportunities to both develop and apply these skills?
  • Content and approaches e.g. do language learning and teaching approaches and learning contexts engage and inspire learners?
  • Intercultural learning g. do learners feel that they are developing their intercultural skills and extending their understanding about the world through their language learning experiences?

How are we doing?

  • Our curriculum is appropriate to our learners’ age and stage and offers progressive pathways for all learners
  • Our language learning is relevant to our learners’ interests and needs and we know this through embedding learner voice throughout our planning, our learning and teaching and our self-evaluation.
  • Our learners understand the range of skills gained through language learning including skills for life and work, literacy, intercultural competency, and global citizenship.

Record your practice

Now you have researched the methodology and best practice in Relevance it's time to record how you are doing. Download the interactive/printable PDF file which you can fill in digitally (or manually if you prefer) for your records and CPD.

Education Scotland, A 1+2 approach to modern languages

Available at: https://education.gov.scot/improvement/learning-resources/a-1-plus-2-approach-to-modern-languages

Education Scotland (2008) Curriculum for Excellence, building the curriculum 3

Available at: https://education.gov.scot/Documents/btc3.pdf

Education Scotland (2017) 1+2 Languages: FAQs and Answers

Available at: https://education.gov.scot/improvement/documents/modlang7-faq-and-answers.pdf

Education Scotland, Modern Languages: Principles and Practice https://education.gov.scot/Documents/modern-languages-pp.pdf

Available at: https://education.gov.scot/Documents/modern-languages-pp.pdf

The Case for Languages

SCILT toolkit of key messages, guidance documents and related websites with information on the importance of language learning for all.

SCILT: Why languages?

SCILT leaflet for parents detailing the benefits of language learning.

SCILT: Languages in a nutshell

British Council report exploring which languages are considered to be key for future development in post-Brexit Britain.

British Council: Languages for the future (2017)

Useful Bilingualism Matters leaflet summarising the cognitive, social and economic benefits of language learning and multilingualism.

Bilingualism Matters: Sell your language skills

Research piece by Bilingualism Matters exploring how language skills and learning impacts on learners’ identity.

Bilingualism Matters: Language, place, and identity

Summary on key benefits for early, primary and secondary learners of languages.

ACTFL Language Connects: Benefits of Language Learning

Language learning across the curriculum

Useful introduction to CLIL including guiding principles and practical advice on getting started.

British Council: A CLIL Lesson Framework

Blog with a useful introduction to CLIL and guidance on getting started.

FluentU

Association for language learning CLIL resources. Offers exemplification from a number of schools.

ALL Languages: CLIL zone

A guide to the opportunities available and the benefits that international engagement can bring in delivering equity and excellence across the curriculum.

Learners International: International Learning Opportunities

This project aims to have students from a Chinese school and students from a Scottish school achieving level one of the award, using their foreign language and their journeys with each other from two different educational and environmental settings across two different countries.

John Muir Award - A Scotland/China Project

Connecting Classrooms supports learning about global issues through working with either a group of schools in the UK or a school in another country

British Council Connecting Classrooms

This website contains examples of lesson plans and activities to support language learning in primary and secondary classes using the CLIL approach to language teaching. Language is taught through another curricular area e.g. numeracy or science.

ELAPSE

Bilingualism Matters is a research and information centre at the University of Edinburgh. It studies bilingualism and language learning, and communicates what it knows to enable people to make informed decisions based on scientific evidence.

Bilingualism Matters

In 2015, world leaders agreed to 17 Global Goals (officially known as the Sustainable Development Goals or SDGs). These goals have the power to create a better world by 2030, by ending poverty, fighting inequality and addressing the urgency of climate change. The website has more information about the goals and how schools can promote use of the Sustainable Development Goals in learning so that children can contribute to a better future for all.

The Global Goals

Poems which can be used by learners in French, Spanish, German and other languages & exemplification on how these could be used

ALL Literature Project

The ENACT website helps people to learn languages through cultural activities around the world. Explanations of how to carry out a favourite cultural activity are given in the target language e.g. origami in Japanese.

ENACT – Learning Language Through Culture